Schopenhauer quotes from On Thinking for Yourself

Lines from “On Thinking for Yourself” in our edition’s new translation from the first edition of 1851. Older translations word them differently.

“Just as the largest library, if it is in disorder, is of less use than a very modest one that is well ordered, so the greatest mass of knowledge, if your own thinking has not worked it through, is worth far less than a much smaller amount that has been thought over from many sides.”

The opening image and the thesis.

“Reading means thinking with someone else’s head instead of your own.”

The most quoted sentence, often stripped of its point: reading is not bad, but it is not thinking.

“Other people’s thoughts, read in books, are the leftovers of someone else’s meal, the cast-off clothes of a stranger.”

“That is why most scholars amount to so little.”

Aimed, almost certainly, at Hegel and his followers.

“People who have spent their lives reading and drawn their wisdom from books are like those who have acquired exact knowledge of a country from many travel books.”

Read them in context in our edition.

Sources
  • Arthur Schopenhauer, “Selbstdenken”, Parerga und Paralipomena, vol. 2, chapter XXII (Berlin: A. W. Hayn, 1851).
  • Thinking School edition: On Thinking for Yourself, translated and annotated, with essays by Julian Delphiki (prologue, context, notes and counterpoints). English translations on these pages are from our edition.