Schopenhauer’s most popular work today is a manuscript he never published: a catalogue of dirty tricks in debate.
The text
Eristische Dialektik, known in English as The Art of Being Right or The Art of Controversy, was written around 1830–31 and left unfinished among his papers. It was published after his death, in 1864.
The idea
Eristic dialectic, he says, is the art of disputing in such a way as to hold one’s own, whether one is in the right or the wrong. People argue to win, not to find truth, because of innate vanity. So it is useful to know the tricks, if only to defend against them.
The stratagems
He lists thirty-eight. Some examples: extend your opponent’s claim beyond its limits, so it is easier to attack (stratagem 1); use the opponent’s own words in a different sense; ask many questions at once to hide what you want admitted; make the opponent angry; claim victory despite defeat; appeal to authority rather than reason. The last, used when all else fails, is to become personal, insulting and rude.
How to read it
It is satire and self-defence manual at once. Each stratagem is now recognisable in online argument. Its opposite is the patient, solitary thinking praised in “Selbstdenken”. Our edition, On Thinking for Yourself, has an essay on looping, a technique for arguing to understand rather than to win.
Sources
- Arthur Schopenhauer, Eristische Dialektik (written c. 1830–31), in Aus Arthur Schopenhauer’s handschriftlichem Nachlaß, ed. J. Frauenstädt (Leipzig, 1864).
- Wikidata (Q38193)
On Thinking for Yourself Before AI Does It for You by Julian Delphiki. Buy the printable PDF (3,99 €) · Find on Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab) · About the book
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.