The Ruin (1907)

Why are ruins beautiful? Simmel gave an answer that still appears in writing on architecture and decay.

Publication

“Die Ruine” was published in 1907 and collected in Philosophische Kultur (1911).

Spirit and nature

Architecture, Simmel says, is the one art in which the struggle between the will of the spirit and the necessity of nature is settled in a real peace: the building raises matter upward according to a human plan, while gravity and materials pull it down. In a ruin, the balance shifts: nature begins to take back what the spirit forced into form.

The charm

The ruin moves us because this reversal is not mere destruction. A new whole appears, in which the human purpose and the work of nature have grown together. Its charm is a peace in which the opposing forces seem reconciled, and its atmosphere includes the past, present in decay.

Not every ruin

A building destroyed by human violence does not have this charm, Simmel notes; nor does an inhabited ruin, a house still lived in while it decays, which is merely sad.

Further reading

For Simmel on the city, the opposite of the ruin, see The Metropolis and Mental Life.

Sources
  • Georg Simmel, “Die Ruine”, in Philosophische Kultur (Leipzig: Klinkhardt, 1911).
  • Wikidata (Q76849)

The Metropolis and Mental Life by Julian Delphiki. Buy the printable PDF (3,99 €) · Find on Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab) · About the book

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.