The most common objection to Thoreau is that it is easy to scorn money when someone else owns the land. Our edition gives the objection a chapter of its own, “Thoreau’s Privilege”, and concludes that it is half right.
The missing line in the budget
In the first chapter of Walden, Thoreau lists the cost of his cabin item by item: twenty-eight dollars and twelve and a half cents. The budget leaves out the land. It belonged to Ralph Waldo Emerson, who had bought it the year before and let Thoreau build there for nothing. The cabin stood about a mile and a half from the village and the family home, where Thoreau went often, as he admits.
What he had
The honest list is long. He was a white Protestant man in 1850s New England. He had been to Harvard when few young men from his town went to college. His family had a modest but steady pencil and graphite business he could work in when he needed money. He never married and had no children, so nobody depended on his income. And his friend, patron and sometimes landlord was the best-connected man in American letters. With that list, his claim that a few weeks’ work a year were enough to live on loses some of its force.
The laundry legend
A detail repeated everywhere says that while he boasted of self-reliance in the woods, his mother did his laundry. There is probably something in it, since he ate at his parents’ house often. But our edition found no direct source that settles it, and the story has the look of a detail that grows with each retelling. Even if true, it would not touch “Life Without Principle”, which is about the price of hours, not about self-sufficiency.
“Pond Scum”
The harshest recent attack came from Kathryn Schulz in The New Yorker in October 2015. She did not bother with the laundry. She called Thoreau a misanthrope and a moralist who judged everyone with a severity he never turned on himself, and argued that Walden is full of contradictions his admirers prefer not to see. Our edition suggests reading her after Thoreau, not before.
What survives
The charge of privilege tells us who could afford to run the experiment. It does not answer the question the essay asks: what do you sell your hours for? That question works just as well for someone with no land and no Emerson, perhaps better. And as the counterpoint admits, the objections that hold against Thoreau hold against anyone, including the editor, who writes about simplicity and is paid for it.
Robert Louis Stevenson called Thoreau a “skulker” in an essay of 1880 and later softened the judgement; see our page on Stevenson. For what Thoreau actually argued, read Life Without Principle, explained.
Sources
- Thinking School edition: Life Without Principle, Annotated, Julian Delphiki (prologue, context chapter, notes and counterpoint).
- Kathryn Schulz, “Pond Scum”, The New Yorker, 19 October 2015.
- Laura Dassow Walls, Henry David Thoreau: A Life (University of Chicago Press, 2017).
- Robert Louis Stevenson, “Henry David Thoreau: His Character and Opinions”, Cornhill Magazine, June 1880; in Familiar Studies of Men and Books (1882).