Walden, Civil Disobedience and Life Without Principle

Most readers know Thoreau through Walden and “Civil Disobedience”. “Life Without Principle” is the third side of the triangle, and the one that holds the other two together.

Walden (1854)

The book reports an experiment: two years, two months and two days in a cabin Thoreau built beside Walden Pond, on land owned by Emerson. Its first chapter, “Economy”, is a household budget turned into philosophy, down to the twenty-eight dollars and twelve and a half cents the cabin cost. The rest moves through the seasons, the pond, reading, neighbours and solitude. It is the book that gave us “lives of quiet desperation” and “simplify, simplify”. Two thousand copies took five years to sell.

Civil Disobedience (1849)

In July 1846 Thoreau spent a night in jail for refusing to pay his poll tax to a government that tolerated slavery and was at war with Mexico. The lecture he made of it, first published in 1849 and later known as “Civil Disobedience”, argues that a person should not lend himself to the wrong he condemns. It reached Tolstoy, Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr., and is his most widely read text.

Life Without Principle (1854–1863)

The lecture he took on tour in the winter after Walden is shorter and angrier than either. It is not about living in the woods or defying the state but about the everyday: what we sell our hours for, the lottery of easy money, and the news that fills whatever time is left. Walden can be admired from the sofa, our edition says; “Life Without Principle” will not let you.

How they fit

All three are about the same thing, which Thoreau called economy: the cost of a thing in the amount of life exchanged for it. Walden shows the sum done at home. “Civil Disobedience” shows the sum refused to the state. “Life Without Principle” applies it to work, money and attention, where most of us spend our days.

Which to read first

If you have an hour, “Life Without Principle”. If you have a weekend, the first chapter of Walden, then the essay, then “Civil Disobedience”. See where to start with Thoreau.

Sources
  • Thinking School edition: Life Without Principle, Annotated, Julian Delphiki (context chapter and further reading).
  • H. D. Thoreau, “Life Without Principle”, The Atlantic Monthly 12 (October 1863), 484–495.
  • Laura Dassow Walls, Henry David Thoreau: A Life (University of Chicago Press, 2017).