Our edition sets one critic of work beside nine essays that mostly agree with him, so it closes with the strongest objections to Wilde, argued with the force they would have from someone who believes them.
Work protects
Critiques of work forget what happens when it is missing. A 2009 meta-analysis by Karsten Paul and Klaus Moser of more than three hundred studies found psychological problems in 34 per cent of unemployed people and 16 per cent of employed people, and evidence that unemployment causes distress rather than merely accompanying it. The psychologist Marie Jahoda explained why: a job provides structure, contact, shared goals, status and regular activity as well as a wage. The objection refutes the idea that work as such is an evil. It does not refute the question of which work, or who keeps what the machine produces.
A privileged man
Wilde wrote his praise of individualism between first nights and dinners, at the height of his success. The objection is fair and has no complete answer. Four years later he was sentenced to two years’ hard labour and did the ugly work himself. And a question asked by a comfortable man is not false for that.
Socialism has been tried
The twentieth century tried abolishing private ownership of the means of production, and the largest attempts ended in authoritarian regimes that made ugly work compulsory. Wilde foresaw it and warned that authoritarian socialism would be worse than what it cured, but he had no workable theory of how to reach the society he imagined. What survives is the diagnosis, not the programme: technology does not reduce work by itself, much work is useless, and the ownership of machines decides whom they benefit.
Progress did reduce work
The working week is far shorter than in 1891, life expectancy has doubled, and machines do most of the brutally physical jobs Wilde wanted them to do. This objection has almost all the long-run data on its side, and our edition concedes it. Its reply is narrower: the gains came through law and bargaining as much as through machines, and the question of who keeps the hour the machine saves is open again with artificial intelligence.
Read the summary of the essay.
Sources
- Thinking School edition: The Soul of Man under Socialism, annotated, with essays by Julian Delphiki (counterpoints).
- Karsten I. Paul and Klaus Moser, “Unemployment impairs mental health: Meta-analyses”, Journal of Vocational Behavior 74 (2009), 264–282.