Wilde’s longest critical dialogue defends the critic, and contemplation, against the cult of action.
Publication
It appeared in two parts in The Nineteenth Century in July and September 1890 as “The True Function and Value of Criticism” and was revised as “The Critic as Artist” for Intentions (1891).
The argument
Two friends, Gilbert and Ernest, talk through a night in a London library. Gilbert argues that criticism is not secondary to creation but a creative art in its own right: the highest criticism treats the work of art as a starting point for a new creation, the record of the critic’s own soul. Without the critical faculty, he adds, there is no artistic creation at all worthy of the name.
In praise of doing nothing
The dialogue’s second part praises contemplation over action. Gilbert says that to do nothing at all is the most difficult thing in the world, the most difficult and the most intellectual; that action is limited and relative, while the vision of the man who sits at ease and watches is unlimited.
Why it matters for the essay
“The Soul of Man under Socialism”, published months later, imagines machines doing the necessary work so that people can do exactly this: contemplate, create and develop their personalities. See The Soul of Man Under Socialism.
Sources
- Oscar Wilde, “The Critic as Artist”, in Intentions (London: Osgood, McIlvaine, 1891).
- Wikidata (Q30875)
The Soul of Man Under Socialism and Other Essays on the Purpose of Modern Work by Julian Delphiki. Buy the printable PDF (3,99 €) · Find on Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab) · About the book
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.