“There’s a sucker born every minute”: the line Barnum never said

Type Barnum’s name into a search engine and, after the film, the next thing is a sentence: “There’s a sucker born every minute.” It is on T-shirts, mugs and marketing slides. There is no evidence he ever said it.

The Cardiff Giant

The usual story starts in October 1869, on a farm at Cardiff, New York, where well diggers unearthed a ten-foot stone giant. It was a fraud, commissioned by a tobacconist, George Hull, carved in gypsum and buried a year earlier. People paid to see it. Hull sold his share to a syndicate headed by a Syracuse banker, David Hannum. Barnum wanted the giant; they would not sell. So he had a plaster copy made and exhibited it in New York as the real one, and people queued to see the copy of the fraud. It was then, the story goes, that Hannum said the line about Barnum’s customers.

Why it survives

Our edition’s first essay argues that the false quotation survives because it flatters whoever repeats it: the sucker is always someone else. Repeating it makes you feel like the showman, not the crowd.

What Barnum actually wrote

In Chapter I of The Humbugs of the World, Barnum wrote the opposite. The man who thinks that everyone is either a sucker or a cheat is not cleverer than everyone else: he is a fool. For a showman, contempt for the public was bad business; he needed people to come back.

The test

Our edition ends every essay with four questions, the shop-window test. Who gets paid? What am I shown, and what am I not allowed to see? Am I buying the thing or access to it? Who promised the same thing five years ago? And one rule above all: if someone asks you for money by phone or video, even with the voice or face of someone you love, hang up and call the number you already had.

Sources
  • Thinking School edition: The Humbugs of the World (Annotated), Julian Delphiki (prologue, context chapter, notes and essays).
  • P. T. Barnum, The Humbugs of the World (New York: G. W. Carleton, 1866).