Four years after writing about spirit photographs in The Humbugs of the World, Barnum took the witness stand against the most famous of the photographers.
Mumler
William H. Mumler, a Boston engraver, began producing “spirit photographs” in the early 1860s: portraits in which a faint figure of a dead relative appeared beside the sitter. Grieving families after the Civil War paid well. In 1869 he was working in New York.
The case
In April 1869 Mumler was charged with fraud and larceny after an investigation instigated by the city’s chief marshal. The hearing became a public spectacle. Spiritualists testified that they had recognised their dead.
Barnum’s testimony
Barnum testified for the prosecution. He explained how such images could be made by double exposure and other photographic tricks, and presented a photograph of himself with the “ghost” of Abraham Lincoln, made by another photographer to show how easily it could be done. He had included a chapter on Mumler’s methods in The Humbugs of the World.
The verdict
The judge discharged Mumler, saying that although he believed fraud had probably been practised, the prosecution had not proved it. Mumler’s best-known later image is a portrait of Mary Todd Lincoln with the apparent ghost of her husband, made in the early 1870s.
Why it matters now
Our edition, The Humbugs of the World, places Chapter XIV beside deepfakes and AI-generated images of the dead, with the objection that today’s fakes are much harder to spot.
Sources
- P. T. Barnum, The Humbugs of the World (1866), ch. XIV.
- Louis Kaplan, The Strange Case of William Mumler, Spirit Photographer (University of Minnesota Press, 2008).
- Wikidata (Q223766)
The Humbugs of the World by Julian Delphiki. Buy the printable PDF (3,99 €) · Find on Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab) · About the book
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.