Reading guide: Tales of Horror and History

A guide for readers and groups to Tales of Horror and History, ten legends traced back to the events behind them.

What the book does

Every legend in the book begins with something that happened. The method is the same each time: the legend as told, the documents, and an explanation of why a simple answer is so often hard to accept.

What is in the book

  1. A Scottish castle said to hide a room no one could find.
  2. A Texas mission defended, the story goes, by figures with flaming swords.
  3. Nine hikers who cut their way out of their tent in a Ural blizzard.
  4. A creature said to walk upright along a road in Wisconsin.
  5. A Victorian murder whose last clue surfaced 131 years later.
  6. The medieval town that lost 130 children to a piper.
  7. A countess accused of bathing in blood.
  8. A ship found sailing with no one aboard.
  9. A “vampire” in the slums of Barcelona.
  10. Faces that rose from a kitchen floor in Andalusia.

Questions readers ask

Is it fiction?

No. It traces legends to the documented events behind them.

Which stories does it cover?

A Scottish castle’s hidden room, a Texas mission, nine hikers in the Urals, a creature on a Wisconsin road, a Victorian murder, the piper of Hamelin, a blood countess, a ship found empty, a Barcelona vampire and the faces of an Andalusian kitchen.

Is it scary?

The subjects are dark; the approach is historical.

Who is it for?

Readers who enjoy mysteries and want the evidence as well as the story.

Questions for discussion

  1. Which explanation in the book was hardest to accept, and why?
  2. Why are simple answers so often less satisfying than strange ones?
  3. How do newspapers and rumour turn events into legends?
  4. Which of the ten stories most deserves to be retold, and how would you tell it honestly?
  5. What do these legends say about the places that keep them alive?

Back to Tales of Horror and History.