Reading guide: What the Water Kept

A guide for readers, book clubs and small groups to What the Water Kept, a Christian romantic suspense novel set on Lake Selah. The novel ends with a note from the author and its own questions; these complement them. This guide avoids spoilers beyond the opening chapters.

The premise

Fifteen years ago, sixteen-year-old Marnie Rawlins vanished from the marina on Lake Selah, and the town decided her pastor had done it. Now the lake has been drawn down to its lowest level since the dam was built, and her car is in the mud. Josie Abernathy has come home to settle her father into memory care and sell the lake house. She stopped praying a long time ago, and she is the only person who can read the shorthand notebook he hid.

Questions readers ask

Is it a clean read?

It is Christian romantic suspense with a faith that has to be lived before it can be said, written for a general Christian readership.

Is it a second-chance romance?

Yes, set in a small town.

Is it part of a series?

It is the first book set at Lake Selah.

Are there questions for groups?

Yes, at the end of the novel.

Questions for discussion

  1. Why does the town decide so quickly that the pastor was guilty?
  2. What does the lowered lake reveal besides a car?
  3. How does caring for a father with memory loss shape Josie’s story?
  4. What does it mean for faith to be lived before it can be said?
  5. What does the title suggest the water kept?

Back to What the Water Kept.