On Thinking for Yourself, explained

“On Thinking for Yourself” is chapter XXII of the second volume of Parerga and Paralipomena, the book of leftover essays Schopenhauer published in 1851, at sixty-three, without a fee. It is short, sharp and, in places, unfair. It is also the best description written before the internet of what too much input does to a mind.

The ordered library

The essay opens with an image: “Just as the largest library, if it is in disorder, is of less use than a very modest one that is well ordered, so the greatest mass of knowledge, if your own thinking has not worked it through, is worth far less than a much smaller amount that has been thought over from many sides.” Knowledge counts only when you have combined it with what you already know.

Thinking with someone else’s head

“Reading means thinking with someone else’s head instead of your own.” Other people’s thoughts in books are “the leftovers of someone else’s meal, the cast-off clothes of a stranger.” Constant reading, without time to think, leaves the mind like a field trampled by others. That is why, he says, most scholars amount to so little: they have read so much that they have lost the habit of seeing for themselves.

Travel books and the country

People who draw all their wisdom from books are like those who know a country only from travel books: they can tell you a great deal and have no clear idea of the place. The independent thinker has been there.

The book philosopher

Schopenhauer contrasts the thinker who looks at the world with the book philosopher who compares, weighs and criticises what others said. It is not hard to guess whom he meant: Hegel, who had filled the lecture hall in Berlin while Schopenhauer’s course, scheduled at the same hour, emptied.

Thoughts arrive like visitors

You cannot think on command. Thoughts come when they will; the right moment must be waited for, and used. Reading can be done at any time; thinking cannot. That is why he treats it as a fault to drive away a thought of your own in order to pick up a book.

Read with care

The essay is the revenge of a rejected man who was right about many things and resentful enough to exaggerate nearly all of them. Our edition’s eighteen essays test it against feeds, AI that finishes our thoughts and schools after ChatGPT. Read the key lines.

Sources
  • Arthur Schopenhauer, “Selbstdenken”, Parerga und Paralipomena, vol. 2, chapter XXII (Berlin: A. W. Hayn, 1851).
  • Thinking School edition: On Thinking for Yourself, translated and annotated, with essays by Julian Delphiki (prologue, context, notes and counterpoints). English translations on these pages are from our edition.