Mackay’s book enjoys, in the historian Andrew Odlyzko’s phrase, an extraordinarily high reputation in finance and the press and an extraordinarily low one among historians. Both can be true at once.
What Mackay says about tulips
That in 1634 the ordinary industry of the country was neglected and the whole population, “even to its lowest dregs”, went into the tulip trade; that nobles, farmers, sailors, maidservants and chimney-sweeps bought bulbs; that the crash reduced merchants to beggary; and that the commerce of the country suffered a shock from which it took many years to recover.
What the archives say
Anne Goldgar spent years in the notarial and municipal archives of Haarlem, Amsterdam, Alkmaar and other Dutch towns, and published Tulipmania in 2007. She found fewer than half a dozen prominent participants in financial trouble after the crash of February 1637, and even for those it is not clear tulips were to blame. No ruined chimney-sweeps, no nobles reduced to beggary, no merchants flinging themselves into canals: well-off merchants and craftsmen who had gambled in a luxury market, lost money, sued each other and got on with their lives.
Where the myths came from
Mackay worked from what was on English library shelves: French court memoirs, Dutch satirical pamphlets, travel books. Many of his sources were already satire when they were written, and he rarely cites them by page.
The railway mania
In 1845 Britain went through the biggest stock-market mania of its century: the railways. In the 1852 edition Mackay added a footnote noting that his first edition had appeared some time before the mania broke out. The note leaves out the important part. In 2011 Odlyzko read what Mackay wrote during the mania in the newspaper he then edited, the Glasgow Argus, and concluded that he had been one of its most ardent cheerleaders.
Why it still matters
The author of the standard book against bubbles did not recognise one in front of him. Our edition does not say this to mock him: it is the best proof of his thesis. The tulip story is less true than useful, and its usefulness keeps it alive.
Sources
- Anne Goldgar, Tulipmania: Money, Honor, and Knowledge in the Dutch Golden Age (University of Chicago Press, 2007).
- Andrew Odlyzko, “Charles Mackay’s own extraordinary popular delusions and the Railway Mania” (2011).
- Thinking School edition: The Madness of Crowds, Mackay’s three chapters on financial manias with essays by Julian Delphiki (prologue, background, notes and counterpoints).