Charles Mackay (1814–1889) was a Scottish poet, journalist and songwriter. He is remembered for one book, Memoirs of Extraordinary Popular Delusions (1841), and within it for three chapters on financial manias: the tulips, the Mississippi scheme and the South Sea bubble.
Charles Mackay at a glance
| Born | 27 March 1814, Perth, Scotland |
|---|---|
| Died | 24 December 1889 |
| Known for | Memoirs of Extraordinary Popular Delusions (1841); second edition titled …and the Madness of Crowds (1852) |
| Profession | Journalist (Morning Chronicle), poet, songwriter |
| Daughter | The novelist Marie Corelli |
| Copyright | Public domain |
The journalist who wrote about manias
Mackay was twenty-seven and working on the Morning Chronicle in London when Richard Bentley published his three volumes in 1841. The book gathered centuries of collective credulity: financial manias, crusades, witch hunts, alchemists, fortune-tellers and prophecies of doom. The second edition of 1852 added the phrase “the Madness of Crowds” to the title.
What he was not
Mackay was not a historian in the modern sense. He worked from what was on English library shelves, many of his sources were already satire, and he rarely cited them. Nor was he an economist: his explanation of bubbles is moral, a matter of greed and imitation. Historians have since corrected much of his tulip story. We read him for the scenes.
And then he joined one
Four years after his book, Britain went through the railway mania of the 1840s, and Mackay was not immune to the enthusiasm. In the 1852 edition he added a footnote acknowledging the railway mania as the new great example of popular infatuation. Our edition opens its background chapter with this irony.
The three manias
Mackay’s book covers witch hunts, alchemists, crusades and prophecies, but it is read for three chapters on money. Tulips in the Dutch Republic, 1634 to 1637, when contracts on bulbs still in the ground changed hands in taverns until, in February 1637, the buyers vanished. John Law’s Mississippi Scheme in France, 1716 to 1720, when a bank, a colonial company and the national debt were rolled into one and shares rose twentyfold before the system broke. And the South Sea Bubble in London in 1720, when a company that barely traded took over Britain’s debt, bribed much of the government and soared from about 130 to nearly 1,000 before collapsing. See the three manias in brief.
A moralist, not a historian
Mackay was not a historian in the modern sense. He worked from French court memoirs, Dutch satirical pamphlets and travel books, many already satire when written. Nor was he an economist: his explanation of bubbles is moral, greed, imitation and credulity, and he ignores interest rates and contracts to look at the dukes queueing in the street. That is his weakness as a historian and his strength as a writer. We read him for the scenes.
The best proof of his thesis
Historians have been unkind. Anne Goldgar’s research in Dutch archives found tulip mania far smaller than Mackay claimed, with fewer than half a dozen prominent participants in trouble afterwards. And in 2011 Andrew Odlyzko showed that Mackay, four years after his book, was one of the most ardent cheerleaders of the railway mania of 1845 in the newspaper he edited. The author of the standard book against bubbles did not recognise one in front of him. See Mackay exaggerated and the biography.
From tulips to tokens
Our edition prints the three chapters with notes, and nine essays that test Mackay’s pattern on the manias of our time: bitcoin and the same old fear of missing out, the question of an AI bubble, the housing crisis, NFTs and memecoins as digital tulips, finfluencers as the town criers of 1720, the difference between a bubble and a fraud, the prophets who predict every crash, and boring investing as a defence. None of it is investment advice. A timeline, a glossary and nine questions close the book. See the FAQ, and compare Barnum, who borrowed Mackay’s tulips for his own book on humbugs.
Why the book never goes out of print
Mackay’s book has never been out of print since 1841. The American financier Bernard Baruch credited its lessons with his decision to sell his stocks before the crash of 1929, and every generation of investors since has rediscovered it at the top of its own mania, usually a few months late. Its appeal is easy to see. The scenes are unforgettable: the hunchback in the Rue Quincampoix renting out his hump as a writing desk to speculators in Law’s shares; the dukes queueing in the street; the bubble companies of 1720, one of them famously “for carrying on an undertaking of great advantage, but nobody to know what it is”. And the moral is simple enough to remember in a hurry: crowds go mad together and recover their senses slowly, one by one. Mackay’s sentence to that effect is the most quoted line in the book.
How to read him now
Our edition suggests reading Mackay as a storyteller with a thesis rather than a historian with evidence, and checking his best stories against the archives before repeating them. The tulip chapter is the weakest on facts and the strongest as a parable. The Mississippi and South Sea chapters are closer to the record, because the collapse of Law’s system and the South Sea scandal left parliamentary inquiries, accounts and lawsuits behind them. Read all three with a question in mind that Mackay does not ask: who was paid to keep the price rising? In 1720, as our edition’s essays on finfluencers and on the difference between a bubble and a fraud show, the answer is often the same as now: promoters, insiders and people paid to talk. The nine questions at the end of our edition are designed to be asked before buying anything that is rising fast.
A guide to this section
The pages below go deeper into Charles Mackay’s life, work and reception. Each is short, sourced and linked back here.
John Law and the Mississippi Scheme. A Scottish gambler who had killed a man in a duel ran France’s finances and created the Mississippi bubble. Who John Law was and what went wrong.
The South Sea Company and the bubble of 1720. In 1720 South Sea Company shares rose from about £128 to around £1,000 and collapsed. The company, the scheme, the Bubble Act and the aftermath.
Isaac Newton and the South Sea Bubble. Newton sold South Sea shares at a profit, bought back near the top and lost heavily. What is known, and the famous line he may not have said.
The Alchymists: Mackay on the search for gold. Mackay’s Extraordinary Popular Delusions has a long chapter on alchemists. Whom he covers and what he thought the delusion was.
The Witch Mania. Mackay devoted a long chapter to the European witch trials. What he wrote, his numbers and how historians see them now.
The Crusades as a popular madness. Mackay included the Crusades in his book of delusions. Peter the Hermit, the People’s Crusade and the Children’s Crusade in his telling.
The Slow Poisoners. Mackay’s chapter on the poisoning fashion of the 17th century covers Italy and Paris. The cases and what he thought spread them.
The Magnetisers: Mesmer and animal magnetism. Mackay’s chapter on animal magnetism tells the story of Franz Anton Mesmer in Paris and the commission, with Franklin, that investigated him.
Haunted Houses and the Cock Lane ghost. Mackay’s chapter on haunted houses tells the story of the Cock Lane ghost, which drew London crowds and Samuel Johnson in 1762.
Popular Follies of Great Cities. Mackay’s chapter on the catchphrases that swept London is an early study of memes. Quoz, “What a shocking bad hat!” and Jim Crow.
Politics, religion and the beard. Mackay has a chapter on how politics and religion governed hair and beards, from Peter the Great’s beard tax to Roundheads and Cavaliers.
Relics. Mackay’s short chapter on relics covers saints’ bones, fragments of the True Cross and the collectors of famous people’s belongings.
Duels and Ordeals. Mackay’s chapter on duels and ordeals runs from medieval trial by combat to the duelling of his own century.
Modern Prophecies and the London earthquake panic of 1761. Mackay collected panics caused by prophecies, including the flood predicted for 1524 and the London earthquake predicted for 1761.
The 1841 and 1852 editions of Mackay’s book. Mackay’s book appeared in three volumes in 1841 and was retitled in 1852, adding “and the Madness of Crowds”. The editions and what changed.
Mackay the songwriter: The Good Time Coming. In his day Mackay was best known for his songs. “The Good Time Coming” and “Cheer! Boys, Cheer!”, and the optimism of a sceptic.
Why this edition
Mackay’s whole book is free online, including long sections on alchemy and witches with nothing to do with money. Ours selects the three money chapters, annotates them, explains where Mackay exaggerated, and adds nine essays on Bitcoin, an AI bubble, housing, NFTs, finfluencers and boring investing, with a timeline and glossary. It gives no investment advice.
- Tulips, the Mississippi and the South Sea: Mackay’s three manias
- Mackay exaggerated: what historians correct
- Charles Mackay: a short biography
- The Madness of Crowds: FAQ
- John Law and the Mississippi Scheme
- The South Sea Company and the bubble of 1720
- Isaac Newton and the South Sea Bubble
- The Alchymists: Mackay on the search for gold
- The Witch Mania
- The Crusades as a popular madness
- The Slow Poisoners
- The Magnetisers: Mesmer and animal magnetism
- Haunted Houses and the Cock Lane ghost
- Popular Follies of Great Cities
- Politics, religion and the beard
- Relics
- Duels and Ordeals
- Modern Prophecies and the London earthquake panic of 1761
- The 1841 and 1852 editions of Mackay’s book
- Mackay the songwriter: The Good Time Coming
Sources
- Thinking School edition: The Madness of Crowds, context chapter (Julian Delphiki).
- Wikidata, Charles Mackay (Q725382)