“The Metropolis and Mental Life” is a lecture of about twenty pages that Georg Simmel gave in Dresden in the winter of 1902–03 and published in 1903. It asks what the big city does to the people who live in it, and it is still the most quoted short text in urban sociology.
The problem
Simmel opens with the claim that the deepest problems of modern life come from the individual’s effort to keep his independence and particularity against the overwhelming powers of society, history, culture and technique. The city is where that struggle is sharpest.
Nerves
The psychological foundation of the city type is “the intensification of nervous life” produced by the swift and uninterrupted change of impressions. The villager lives in slow, habitual rhythms; the city dweller is bombarded. To protect himself, he reacts with his head rather than his heart.
Money and calculation
Cities have always been the seats of the money economy, and money and intellect are deeply connected: both treat people and things as quantities. “The modern mind has become more and more a calculating one.” The same exactness appears in time: if all the clocks in Berlin went wrong by an hour, its whole economic life would be thrown into disorder. Punctuality, calculability and precision are forced on the city dweller.
The blasé attitude
The result is the most famous idea in the lecture: the blasé attitude, an indifference to the differences between things. Overstimulated nerves stop reacting; everything seems equally grey, and money, which expresses every difference as “how much?”, completes the levelling.
Reserve
Towards other people the city dweller adopts reserve: we do not know our neighbours, and behind politeness there is often a slight aversion. Simmel does not condemn it. It is what makes city life possible, and it is also what gives a kind of personal freedom unknown in small towns.
Freedom and the struggle to be someone
The city frees people from the narrow control of the village, but in the crowd it is hard to be noticed. Hence the city’s extravagances and eccentricities: the effort to be someone. The lecture ends refusing to judge: it is our task not to accuse or pardon, but to understand. Read the best lines.
Sources
- Georg Simmel, “Die Großstädte und das Geistesleben”, in Theodor Petermann (ed.), Die Großstadt (Dresden: Gehe-Stiftung, 1903).
- Thinking School edition: The Metropolis and Mental Life, translated and annotated, with essays by Julian Delphiki (prologue, context chapter, notes and counterpoints). English translations of Simmel on these pages are from our edition.