A study guide for “Life Without Principle”, for a class in literature, history or philosophy, or a book club. One or two sessions; nothing needed but the essay.
Before reading
- Write down how many hours you sold last week, counting the commute and messages after hours.
- Write down the last three news items you read. Did any of them change what you did that day?
The lecturer
- Thoreau opens by refusing to tell his audience what it wants to hear. Why start a paid lecture that way? Is it arrogance or honesty?
Getting a living
- Explain the contrast between the man who walks in the woods and the speculator who cuts them down. Who is called industrious, and why?
- “The ways by which you may get money almost without exception lead downward.” Find one exception in your own experience.
- Apply his test to a job you know: would anyone do it for love of it? Does it matter if not?
- Thoreau worked as a surveyor and says clients wanted him to measure in their favour. What is he saying about honest work for dishonest ends?
The gold rush
- Why does he call gold-digging a lottery rather than a bad investment? What would he say about a modern lottery, a meme stock or a cryptocurrency?
- “Men rush to California and Australia as if the true gold were to be found in that direction.” Where does he think it is?
The news
- Thoreau thinks one newspaper a week may be too much. Is he right in 1854? In 2026?
- What does the Kossuth hat tell us about public excitement?
- “Read not the Times. Read the Eternities.” What are the eternities for you?
Politics
- Why the gizzard? What did Boston’s return of Anthony Burns in 1854 have to do with this essay?
Discussion
- Thoreau had Emerson’s land, a family business and no dependants. Does that cancel his argument?
- Which of the three fevers (work, easy money, news) do you catch most easily?
- Compare the essay with Keynes’s “Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren” (1930). See our Keynes study guide.
Exercise: Thoreau’s sum
Our edition ends with a one-page worksheet. Divide your monthly pay by the hours you sell to get an hourly rate; divide your rent or mortgage by it to see how many hours a month you work for a roof; do the same for each debt. Then list three expenses that would survive if nobody could see them, and three that would not. The result does not say how to live. It says what the life you already live costs, in Thoreau’s unit.
Sources
- H. D. Thoreau, “Life Without Principle”, The Atlantic Monthly 12 (October 1863), 484–495.
- Thinking School edition: Life Without Principle, Annotated, Julian Delphiki.