A study guide for “Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren”, for a seminar, a book club or a class in economics, history or philosophy. It takes one or two sessions and needs nothing but the essay; page references are to sections I and II of the text.
Before reading
- Write down how many hours you worked last week, paid and unpaid. Keep the number for the end.
- Ask the group to guess how much richer the average person in their country is than in 1930. Write the guesses down.
Section I: the forecast
- Keynes opens by attacking “economic pessimism”. What was the mood of 1930, eight months after the Wall Street crash? Is there a similar mood now?
- He says the standard of life barely changed for four thousand years before 1700. What two reasons does he give? Are they convincing?
- Work through his Drake sum: £40,000 at 3¼ per cent a year from 1580 to 1930. Does it give £4 billion? (Our edition’s note: it gives about £2.9 billion, the same order of magnitude.)
- What does he mean by “technological unemployment”? Why does he call it a temporary phase?
- His forecast is four to eight times richer in a hundred years. Compare with the guesses made before reading. (US income per head rose about 7.3 times from 1930 to 2022.)
Section II: the permanent problem
- Explain the difference between absolute and relative needs in your own words. Give one example of each from your own spending.
- Why does Keynes think leisure will be a problem? Who is his example, and what does the example tell you about his point of view?
- Why a fifteen-hour week? Is it a goal or a way of sharing work?
- What does he mean by “purposiveness” and “jam to-morrow”? Do you recognise the attitude in yourself?
- “For at least another hundred years we must pretend… that fair is foul and foul is fair.” Is this cynicism, irony or realism?
- List his four conditions for reaching “economic bliss”. Which have been met? What does the first one, population control, tell you about Keynes in 1930?
- The essay ends with dentists. Why?
Discussion
- Keynes got the wealth right and the hours wrong. Which explanation persuades you most: people chose goods over time; the menu of jobs was fixed by others; efficiency was spent on producing more; status; or what we measure?
- Is the essay a utopia for one class? Does that cancel its question?
- Should the uncomfortable passages be cut from modern editions, printed with notes, or left without comment?
- Will artificial intelligence bring the fifteen-hour week closer, or repeat what happened after 1930?
Exercise: the fifty-three weeks sum
Our edition ends with a worksheet. Add up what you pay in a year for housing and essentials, divide by your weekly take-home pay, and count the weeks of work they cost. Add the hours of commuting and answering work out of hours. What is left is, roughly, the time you work for everything else. Compare it with the number you wrote down before reading.
Further reading for the group
See books about Keynes and criticism of the essay.
Sources
- J. M. Keynes, Essays in Persuasion (London: Macmillan, 1931).
- Thinking School edition: We Are the Grandchildren, Julian Delphiki (appendix, “The Fifty-Three Weeks Sum”, and counterpoints).