Keynes’s essay is admired for its arithmetic and attacked for almost everything else. These are the strongest objections, in their best form, with what survives of each. Our edition gives them a whole chapter, “Counterpoints”, including the case against its own argument.
“A Bloomsbury gentleman’s utopia”
When Keynes describes the good life of his grandchildren, he describes the life he and his friends already led: writers, painters and critics with private incomes, servants and country houses. In Revisiting Keynes (2008), economists including four Nobel laureates broadly agreed that he was right about growth but underestimated people’s appetite for work and consumption, perhaps because he modelled economic bliss on the English gentleman. The fair reply is that a biased picture of abundance does not cancel the question of what to do with it.
“People chose consumption, and chose well”
Offered fifteen hours a week at 1930 living standards or forty hours at today’s, almost everyone would take the second, because today includes antibiotics, central heating and decades more life. This is the strongest objection, and our edition does not claim to refute it. It points out only that the choice is made from a menu nobody chose: standard full-time contracts, expensive housing and the penalty for part-time work.
“Work is not a problem to be solved”
For many people work gives structure, company and a sense of use. Keynes half agreed: he thought “the old Adam” would be strong in us for ages and that everybody would need some work to be content. The disagreement is about how much.
Rich men’s wives
His example of the dangers of leisure is the “nervous breakdown” common among “the wives of the well-to-do classes”, deprived of their traditional tasks. It assumes housework is women’s natural occupation and says nothing of the women who did the work in those houses.
The antisemitic allusion
In the passage on purposiveness, Keynes alludes to a “race” that joined the promise of immortality to compound interest. The allusion is to the Jews and repeats a stereotype common in his circle. It is not isolated: such remarks appear in other writings, mostly private, and historians disagree about their weight.
“Our power to control population”
The first of his four conditions for progress is population control. Keynes was a declared neo-Malthusian and held senior office in the British Eugenics Society between 1937 and 1944. The phrase is not innocent.
Why print it whole
Our edition reproduces all three passages unchanged, with notes. Cutting the uncomfortable parts of a 1930 text would be another way of falsifying it. For the evidence on hours, see Was Keynes right?
Sources
- Thinking School edition: We Are the Grandchildren, Julian Delphiki (context chapter, notes, counterpoints and further reading).
- Lorenzo Pecchi and Gustavo Piga (eds.), Revisiting Keynes: Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren (MIT Press, 2008).
- J. M. Keynes, “Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren”, in Essays in Persuasion (London: Macmillan, 1931).