Keynes made two predictions for 2030: that living standards in rich countries would be four to eight times higher than in 1930, and that a fifteen-hour week would be enough. With the deadline close, the short answer is that he got the wealth almost exactly right and the hours badly wrong.
The half that came true
Real income per head in the United States multiplied about 7.3 times between 1930 and 2022, according to the national accounts used in our edition, inside his range and near the top. Switzerland, another well-measured rich country, is at about six times. For a forecast made with schoolroom arithmetic in the middle of a slump, before a world war and a population boom he did not expect, that is a remarkable result. He was right too that farming would need a fraction of the people it once did.
The half that did not
The standard American working week has been forty hours since 1940. A bill to cut it to thirty-two was introduced in the Senate in 2024 and went nowhere. In Spain, where Keynes first gave the lecture, parliament rejected a cut from 40 to 37.5 hours in September 2025. Nobody works fifteen hours a week as a matter of course.
Less wrong than it looks
The economic historian Nicholas Crafts made the strongest case for Keynes. Weekly hours fell less than he expected, but people now live much longer, start work later and spend many years in retirement. Counting the whole life, Crafts estimated that expected lifetime hours of leisure and home production in Britain rose by about 60 per cent between 1931 and 2011, more than Keynes would have expected. The free time came, but at the end of life rather than during the week.
Why the hours stuck
Economists disagree. Some say people chose more goods over more leisure, and chose well: 2026 includes antibiotics, central heating and thirty more years of life. Others point to things nobody chose: standard full-time contracts, housing costs, the penalty for part-time work. Our edition, We Are the Grandchildren, argues the obstacle was never technical, and names five leaks through which the time escaped: efficiency spent on producing more, services that keep getting dearer, the fear of losing your job, status, and what we choose to measure.
A factory that tried
On 1 December 1930, W. K. Kellogg moved his cereal plant in Battle Creek, Michigan, from three eight-hour shifts to four six-hour shifts, to make room for more workers during the Depression. Parts of the plant kept the six-hour day for about half a century. The historian Benjamin Kline Hunnicutt wrote a book on it. Its slow end, department by department, is one of the best answers to why Keynes’s week never came.
For the arguments against Keynes, read criticism of the essay.
Sources
- Thinking School edition: We Are the Grandchildren, Julian Delphiki (context chapter, essays, notes and counterpoints).
- Nicholas Crafts, “The 15-Hour Week: Keynes’s Prediction Revisited”, Economica 89(356), 2022, 815–829.
- Lorenzo Pecchi and Gustavo Piga (eds.), Revisiting Keynes: Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren (MIT Press, 2008).
- Benjamin Kline Hunnicutt, Kellogg’s Six-Hour Day (Temple University Press, 1996).
- J. M. Keynes, “Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren”, in Essays in Persuasion (London: Macmillan, 1931).