Keynes in Madrid, 10 June 1930

Most readers meet “Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren” as an article from London. Before it was printed, it was a lecture in Madrid, given on the afternoon of 10 June 1930 at the Residencia de Estudiantes, four months before it appeared in The Nation and Athenaeum.

The invitation

Keynes was invited by the Comité Hispano-Inglés, a body chaired by the Duke of Alba that had been bringing British speakers to the Residencia since 1923. He travelled with Lydia Lopokova. The title he announced was more cautious than the one he later published: “Possible Economic Situation of our Grandchildren”. He was forty-six, finishing A Treatise on Money and sitting on the committee of economists that advised the Labour government on unemployment.

The room

The Residencia, on the hill of the Chopos in Madrid, was the most cosmopolitan address in Spanish intellectual life. Lorca, Dalí and Buñuel had lived there; Bergson had lectured there in 1916; in 1930 so did the architect Walter Gropius and the astrophysicist Arthur Eddington. The audience came largely from what the historian Bernat Sellarès calls Madrid’s educated bourgeoisie, and Sellarès also traces Keynes’s contact with the city’s aristocracy during the visit. There is no surviving list of who sat in the room, and we will not invent one.

What they heard

Wall Street had crashed eight months earlier. The audience was probably expecting a lecture on the crisis. Instead Keynes told them that in a hundred years the economic problem would be solved, and that their grandchildren’s real problem would be what to do with their leisure. According to the study of the visit, his optimism caused surprise. Sellarès also found that Keynes signed an autograph for an eight-year-old girl, telling her she was living in the midst of the creation of what is most noble and desirable in civilisation.

From lecture to essay

Keynes had tried the ideas out in 1928 with small audiences in England. After Madrid he published the essay in two instalments, on 11 and 18 October 1930, and collected it in Essays in Persuasion in 1931. The Residencia printed a Spanish summary in its review in 1932 under the title “Posible situación económica de nuestros nietos”.

After 1930

The lecture was optimistic; the decade was not. Spain became a republic in April 1931, and the civil war that began in 1936 ended the Residencia as Keynes had known it. The first condition of his forecast, “assuming no important wars”, lasted nine years.

Our edition opens with this story because it is the one most English-language readers have never heard, and because the Madrid audience was the first to hear the question the book asks: why we still work so much. Read the summary of the essay or the timeline.

Sources
  • Bernat Sellarès, “Keynes in Madrid and the delightful people”, Iberian Journal of the History of Economic Thought 7(2), 2020, 165–170.
  • Thinking School edition: We Are the Grandchildren, Julian Delphiki (context chapter, essays, notes and counterpoints).
  • J. M. Keynes, “Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren”, in Essays in Persuasion (London: Macmillan, 1931).