Montaigne and La Boétie: the friendship

Étienne de La Boétie was a fellow magistrate in Bordeaux and the closest friend Michel de Montaigne ever had. They knew each other for about four years before La Boétie died in 1563, aged thirty-two. Montaigne’s essay “Of Friendship” explains the bond in one line: because it was he, because it was I.

Who La Boétie was

La Boétie, born in 1530 in Sarlat in the Périgord, was a councillor in the Parlement of Bordeaux, a poet and a translator of the classics. As a young man he wrote the Discourse on Voluntary Servitude, which asks why whole peoples obey a single ruler they could refuse; tyranny, he argues, rests on consent. The text circulated in manuscript and was later taken up by Protestant pamphleteers, which worried Montaigne.

How they met

Montaigne joined the Parlement of Bordeaux in 1557, and there the two men met. In “Of Friendship” (Essays I.28) he says they had heard of each other before meeting, and that from their first conversation they were bound. He insists the friendship was rare: the kind of union that happens, he thought, perhaps once in three centuries.

“Because it was he, because it was I”

Asked why he loved La Boétie, Montaigne answers that he cannot explain it except by saying “because it was he, because it was I” (in French, parce que c’était lui, parce que c’était moi). The sentence is not in the editions printed in his lifetime. Montaigne added it by hand in the margins of the Bordeaux Copy, the second half apparently later than the first: the most famous line on friendship grew over years, like the book.

The death

La Boétie fell ill in August 1563 and died within days, with Montaigne at his side. Montaigne wrote a long letter to his father describing the death, which was printed later. He also edited and published La Boétie’s works and planned to set the Discourse at the centre of his own first book, then decided against it and printed sonnets instead.

Why it matters for the Essays

Many readers think the Essais took the friend’s place: a conversation Montaigne could no longer have aloud. Our edition of On Solitude includes an essay, “Friends in the Tower”, that sets this friendship beside the solitude Montaigne chose a few years after losing it.

Friendship and solitude

“Of Friendship” and “On Solitude” belong together. Montaigne wrote the first about a friend he had lost in 1563 and the second years later, in a tower he had made his own. The perfect friendship he describes, two souls blended so completely that the seam disappears, is the opposite of solitude and its condition: having known it, he could be alone without being lonely. He also admits it happens once in three centuries. Our study guide pairs the two essays for discussion.

The friendship and the solitude that followed it are read together in On Solitude. Buy the printable PDF (3,99 €) · Find on Amazon (opens Amazon in a new tab) · About the book

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

More on the Discourse on Voluntary Servitude

La Boétie’s short treatise argues that a tyrant has only the power his subjects give him, and that if they simply stopped obeying, without violence, he would fall. Montaigne first meant to print it at the centre of Book I of the Essais, then withdrew it once Protestant writers had published it as a political weapon in the 1570s. He printed twenty-nine of La Boétie’s sonnets in its place in the 1580 edition, and later removed those too.

Sources
  • Thinking School edition: Montaigne, On Solitude, translation from the 1595 text, notes and context (2026).
  • Philippe Desan, Montaigne: A Life (Princeton University Press, 2017).
  • Sarah Bakewell, How to Live (Chatto & Windus, 2010).