A study guide for Montaigne’s “On Solitude” (De la solitude, book I, chapter 39), for a class, a seminar or a reading group. Two sessions: one on the essay, one on the essays around it. Page references are to our edition.
Before reading
- When were you last alone for an hour without a screen? Write down where and why.
- Is there a difference between being alone and being lonely? Write one sentence on each.
Session one: the essay
- Montaigne opens by setting aside the old debate between the active and the solitary life. Why does he say the question of ambition is beside the point?
- He argues that leaving the city is not enough: we carry our chains with us. What are the chains? Can you name your own?
- “The greatest thing in the world is to know how to belong to oneself.” What does belonging to oneself mean, practically?
- Explain the image of the back shop (arrière-boutique). Why a shop, and not a hermitage?
- He quotes Pliny and Cicero, then criticises them for wanting fame from their retirement. What is wrong with writing in solitude for glory?
- He wrote this essay in his library tower after selling his seat in the Parlement in 1570, and then spent much of the next twenty years in public service. Is the essay contradicted by his life?
- Which pleasures does he allow the solitary person? Which does he warn against?
Session two: Montaigne around it
- Read “Of Friendship”. How do friendship and solitude fit together for Montaigne?
- Read the end of “Of Experience”: “when I dance, I dance”. Is this the same idea as the back shop, twenty years later?
- Compare “Of Cannibals”. What does looking at your own customs as a stranger have to do with solitude?
Discussion
- Is remote work solitude or its opposite?
- Is a companion chatbot a back shop, or a shop that never closes?
- Montaigne separates the solitude we choose from the loneliness that happens to us. Where does grief belong? Old age?
- Our edition’s thirteen essays take these questions one at a time. Choose one essay and argue against it.
Writing exercise
Write a short essay in Montaigne’s manner: one page, on one ordinary habit of your own, with at least one quotation you disagree with and no conclusion. Then revise it a week later by adding, not cutting, as Montaigne did in the margins of the Bordeaux Copy.
For the teacher
The essay takes about forty minutes to read aloud. Useful background: the tower and library, the biography and the quotes in French and English.
Sources
- Michel de Montaigne, Essais (Paris: Abel L’Angelier, 1595).
- Thinking School edition: Montaigne, On Solitude, translated and annotated, with essays by Julian Delphiki.