“Of Experience” is the thirteenth and last chapter of the third book, and so the end of the Essais. Many readers think it the best thing Montaigne wrote. It is the essay of a man in his fifties, ill, who has stopped trying to be wise and is trying to live well.
Laws cannot cover life
It opens with knowledge and law. We want to know, and when reason fails we turn to experience. But experience is endlessly varied: no two eggs are alike, no two cases. France, he notes, has more laws than the rest of the world, and more lawsuits, because every new law breeds new doubts. The magistrate who had spent thirteen years in the Parlement of Bordeaux distrusts the idea that rules can foresee life.
Studying himself
So he turns to the one subject he can observe closely: himself. “I study myself more than any other subject; that is my metaphysics, that is my physics” (our translation). The rest of the essay is a long account of his habits: how he sleeps, eats, dresses, how he deals with the cold, with doctors and with his own body.
The stone
Montaigne had suffered from kidney stones since his forties. Here he writes about the pain in detail and without self-pity, and about the bargain he has struck with it: the stone teaches him what philosophy could not, to be ready to leave life without regret. He prefers this teacher to the doctors, whom he mocks throughout the book.
“When I dance, I dance”
The most quoted passage comes near the end: when I dance, I dance; when I sleep, I sleep; and when I walk alone in a beautiful orchard, if my thoughts wander off for a while, I bring them back to the walk, to the orchard, to the sweetness of that solitude and to myself. It is the line most often borrowed by modern writing on attention, usually without the solitude.
Sitting on our own bottom
The essay rises towards a conclusion that mixes the high and the low. However high we climb on stilts, we still walk on our own legs; and on the highest throne in the world we are still sitting on our own bottom. The most beautiful lives, he says, are those that conform to the common human pattern, in order, without miracle and without extravagance. He ends with a prayer to Apollo, from Horace, for a healthy old age that keeps its mind and is not without song.
Where to go next
Read it with On Solitude, which asks how to belong to oneself, and with the page on Montaigne’s death.
Sources
- Michel de Montaigne, Essais (Paris: Abel L’Angelier, 1595). Translations on this page are our own.
- Philippe Desan, Montaigne: A Life (Princeton University Press, 2017).
- Sarah Bakewell, How to Live: A Life of Montaigne in One Question and Twenty Attempts at an Answer (Chatto & Windus, 2010).