In “On Solitude” (Essays, Book I, chapter 39) Michel de Montaigne argues that withdrawal is worth nothing if we carry our ambitions and worries with us. Real solitude is inward: keep a “back shop” of the mind that belongs to you alone, while family, work and property stay in the front room.
Where the chapter comes from
Montaigne wrote it in the first years after his retirement of 1571, when he was reading Seneca and the Stoics “like a man looking for a manual”, as our context chapter puts it, and he retouched it in later editions. It is chapter 39 of Book I in modern numbering (38 in 1595). Seneca’s Letters to Lucilius supply much of the argument; Horace is quoted eight times.
The argument, step by step
Not the old debate
He opens by setting aside the comparison between the active and the contemplative life. Those who say we are born for the public good, he suggests, are often using the phrase to cover ambition. Ambition itself, he notes, gives us a taste for solitude: what does it seek more than elbow room?
Leaving is not enough
Changing place does not cure us, because we take ourselves along. Following Horace, he says that cares are removed by reason and good sense, not by a house with a view of the sea; a sick man moved to another bed is no better. The soul must be withdrawn from the crowd, not just the body.
The back shop
The centre of the chapter is an image from a shopkeeper’s house. In our translation: “We must set aside a back shop all our own, entirely free, in which to establish our true liberty, our principal retreat and solitude.” We may have wives, children, property and health, he says, but must not be so attached to them that our happiness depends on them.
Belonging to oneself
The line most often quoted from the chapter is that “the greatest thing in the world is to know how to belong to oneself”. Montaigne says this as a man of thirty-eight who believes he has given the world his active years. He then sets out a modest programme: avoid passions that disturb body and soul, take up study, hunting or estate management only as far as they give pleasure, and “let each one know how to go his own way”.
Against glory
The chapter ends by rejecting the advice of Pliny and Cicero to use retirement to win fame through writing. Solitude for the sake of reputation is still company: we have only changed audiences.
Solitude and loneliness
English has two words where Montaigne’s French had one: solitude, which is chosen, and loneliness, which happens to us. The chapter is almost entirely about the first. Today it is mostly read from inside the second, and that is the gap our edition explores in thirteen essays on remote work, phones, companion chatbots, grief and old age.
A paradox in the author’s life
Montaigne wrote this chapter and then spent much of his life in public: two terms as mayor of Bordeaux, missions between kings, travels. Our edition reads the chapter as advice written in the back shop and carried out with the shop open. See the biography and the tower and the library.
Using the essay today
The essay has an unusual practical side. Its advice is not to leave the world but to keep one room free of it: the back shop, where we talk to ourselves without witnesses. Our edition tests that idea against remote work, phones, companion chatbots, grief and old age, and distinguishes throughout between the solitude we choose and the loneliness that happens to us. For a class or reading group there is a study guide with questions on each part of the essay and a short writing exercise in Montaigne’s manner.
Sources
- Thinking School edition: Montaigne, On Solitude, translation from the 1595 text, notes and context (2026).
- Seneca, Letters to Lucilius (public domain).