The Humbugs of the World was published in New York in 1866, revised from articles Barnum had written for the New York Weekly Mercury. Its fifty chapters catalogue mediums, quacks, false princes, financial bubbles, witches, oracles and ghosts, written by the man who knew the trade better than anyone.
Humbug is everywhere
Chapter I argues that humbug is “an astonishingly wide-spread phenomenon—in fact almost universal”: in religion, politics and every business. It ends warning that the man who thinks everyone is a sucker or a cheat is no cleverer than anyone else.
Humbug versus swindle
Chapter II is the key. Barnum defines humbug as putting on glittering appearances to attract the public, while still delivering what was promised; the swindler takes the money and delivers nothing. It is a self-serving distinction, since it puts Barnum and his friends on the right side, but it is not a foolish one. A hatter who paid a fortune for the first ticket to Jenny Lind’s concert and sold hats on the publicity is his model.
The spiritualists
Much of the book is a campaign against the mediums, then at their height. Barnum exposes their tricks, offers $500 to any medium who will perform in a room of his choosing, and dissects the spirit photographs of William Mumler, at whose trial he later testified.
Quacks, bubbles and ropers
Other chapters cover patent medicines, Peter Funk’s mock auctions with their planted bidders, lotteries and prize swindles, and financial manias, some borrowed from Charles Mackay’s Extraordinary Popular Delusions (1841).
What is missing
Neither Joice Heth nor the Feejee Mermaid appears. The book needs its author outside the catalogue, looking in. Read it with both eyes open: one for what Barnum teaches, the other for what he leaves out. See the biography and the line he never said.
Sources
- P. T. Barnum, The Humbugs of the World (New York: G. W. Carleton, 1866).
- Thinking School edition: The Humbugs of the World (Annotated), Julian Delphiki (prologue, context chapter, notes and essays).