A study guide for “Self-Reliance”, for a class, seminar or reading group, with tests adapted from our edition’s Concord Notebook.
Questions
- “Envy is ignorance; imitation is suicide.” What is Emerson claiming about envy?
- What is the “iron string” in “Trust thyself”? Is it the same thing as following your feelings?
- Why does Emerson call society a joint-stock company?
- The great man keeps “the independence of solitude” in the crowd. Where is that hardest for you: work, family, online?
- Read the hobgoblin sentence with and without “foolish”. What changes?
- “To be great is to be misunderstood.” Why is this sentence dangerous?
- Emerson travelled to Europe in 1833 and called travel a fool’s paradise in 1841. Is he describing himself?
- “Are they my poor?” Argue for and against his view of charity.
- Find the passages on the New Zealander and on Saxon breasts. Should modern editions print them? With what?
- What does “Nothing can bring you peace but the triumph of principles” add to the line before it?
Week-long tests
- The feed. For seven days, before opening any social app, write one line on what interests you today. At the end, compare with what you ended up watching.
- The draft. Write the first draft of something that matters to you by hand before asking any machine to improve it. Note what it suggests cutting.
- Looking. Watch one small piece of the world, a street, a tree, a trade, for ten minutes a day without looking anything up about it.
- Silence. Five minutes a day with no input. Note what turns up.
Compare
Thoreau, Emerson’s neighbour, lived the essay more literally; see the Thoreau study guide.
Sources
- Ralph Waldo Emerson, “Self-Reliance”, in Essays: First Series (1847).
- Thinking School edition: Self-Reliance in the Age of the Algorithm, Julian Delphiki (counterpoint, epilogue and the Concord Notebook).