“An Apology for Idlers” appeared in the Cornhill Magazine in July 1877, when Stevenson was twenty-six, and was collected in Virginibus Puerisque in 1881. It takes about half an hour to read. It is a plea, in the old sense of apology, for people who do a great deal that nobody counts as work.
An invented crime
The essay opens with a joke that is also its thesis. Everyone, Stevenson says, is bound to enter some lucrative profession and labour in it “with something not far short of enthusiasm”, under pain of being convicted in absence of a crime he invents for the occasion: lese-respectability. Idleness “does not consist in doing nothing, but in doing a great deal not recognised in the dogmatic formularies of the ruling class.”
The school of the street
The longest part is about education. Stevenson, who played truant from his engineering lectures, says he does not regret the hours of truantry but the dull ones in class. The truant learns in the open street and in the country what no syllabus teaches: “to play the fiddle, to know a good cigar, or to speak with ease and opportunity to all varieties of men.” He stages a dialogue between a young idler and a pompous elder, Mr Worldly Wiseman from Bunyan, who cannot imagine learning anything outside a book.
Busyness as a symptom
The most quoted sentence turns the moral tables: “Extreme busyness, whether at school or college, kirk or market, is a symptom of deficient vitality; and a faculty for idleness implies a catholic appetite and a strong sense of personal identity.” The busy man is not virtuous but empty; he has nothing to fall back on when the work stops.
The duty of being happy
Near the end Stevenson argues that there is no duty we underrate so much as the duty of being happy. “A happy man or woman is a better thing to find than a five-pound note,” and their entrance into a room is “as though another candle had been lighted.” If a person cannot be happy without remaining idle, idle he should remain. Then the sentence that gives the game away: it is a revolutionary precept, but “thanks to hunger and the workhouse”, not easily abused.
How to read it
Stevenson exaggerates on purpose and quotes from memory: Bunyan, Shakespeare, Johnson, Hazlitt, Dickens. Read it as a treatise and you miss the jokes; read it only as a joke and you miss the argument. And read it knowing who wrote it: the only son of a prosperous family, living on his father’s money. Our page on idleness as privilege takes that objection seriously.
Sources
- R. L. Stevenson, “An Apology for Idlers”, Cornhill Magazine 36 (July 1877); in Virginibus Puerisque and Other Papers (London: C. Kegan Paul, 1881).
- Thinking School edition: An Apology for Idlers (Annotated), Julian Delphiki (prologue, context chapter, notes, counterpoint and further reading).