Idleness as privilege: the case against Stevenson

The strongest objection to “An Apology for Idlers” is that its idleness belonged to a few. Our edition’s counterpoint essay grants the charge in full, and then disagrees with what usually follows from it.

The charge

When he wrote the essay, Stevenson was twenty-six, the only son of a prosperous Edinburgh family, had refused two professions his father had paid for, and lived on family money. The “we” of the essay are young men like him, choosing among the liberal professions, able to play truant without wrecking their lives. There is not one labourer in it. The only poor person is a barefoot boy with a marble, there to show how happy people cheer others up. Women barely appear. Whoever cooked and washed in the houses of Edinburgh’s idle young men is nowhere.

Stevenson knew

After stating his revolutionary precept, that a person who cannot be happy without idleness should stay idle, he adds that it is not easily abused “thanks to hunger and the workhouse”. It is a brilliant and terrible sentence: the defence of idleness is safe because most people will never be able to practise it.

Veblen and Aristotle

In The Theory of the Leisure Class (1899), Thorstein Veblen described how the upper classes displayed their standing through conspicuous leisure. Read beside Veblen, Stevenson’s idler is not a rebel against respectability but one of its emblems. The charge is older still: the leisure Aristotle praised belonged to free male citizens whose households ran on the work of slaves and women, as he says plainly in the Politics.

The figures now

According to Eurostat, 27.5 per cent of people in the European Union could not afford a single week’s holiday away from home in 2025; in Romania 61 per cent, in Spain nearly a third. In the United States, which has no legal right to paid holiday, about one private-sector worker in five had no paid vacation days. In Britain, millions put in unpaid overtime every week.

The conclusion

Our edition argues that the objection is right in its diagnosis and wrong in its conclusion. If idleness is a privilege, what follows is not that we should stop defending it but that we should share it. The essay’s descendants, from Paul Lafargue’s The Right to Be Lazy (1880) to Bertrand Russell’s case for a four-hour day, made exactly that move. Read the summary of the essay and compare Keynes’s version of the same question, in Was Keynes right?

Sources
  • Thinking School edition: An Apology for Idlers (Annotated), Julian Delphiki (prologue, context chapter, notes, counterpoint and further reading).
  • Thorstein Veblen, The Theory of the Leisure Class (1899).