Keynes and the grandchildren essay: FAQ

Short answers to the questions readers ask most about Keynes and “Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren”.

When did Keynes write the essay?

He tried the ideas out in 1928, gave them as a lecture in Madrid on 10 June 1930, published the essay in The Nation and Athenaeum on 11 and 18 October 1930, and collected it in Essays in Persuasion in 1931.

What exactly did he predict?

That living standards in progressive countries would be four to eight times higher a hundred years later, and that the economic problem would be solved or in sight, assuming no important wars and no important increase in population. He suggested three-hour shifts or a fifteen-hour week to share out the remaining work.

Did he say we would work fifteen hours a week by 2030?

Not quite. He said a fifteen-hour week “may put off the problem for a great while”, the problem being what to do with leisure. It was a way of sharing work, not a target.

Was he right?

About wealth, yes: US income per head rose about 7.3 times between 1930 and 2022. About hours, no. But lifetime leisure rose a great deal, mostly through longer retirement. See Was Keynes right?

What is technological unemployment?

His phrase for unemployment caused by labour-saving outrunning the pace at which we find new uses for labour. He thought it a temporary phase.

Is the essay in the public domain?

Keynes died in 1946, so his works are in the public domain in countries where copyright lasts seventy years after death, including the UK and the EU. Check the rules where you live.

How long is it?

About 6,000 words; under an hour to read.

Why does it mention rich men’s wives, Jews and population control?

Because Keynes wrote from the comfortable British class of 1930. Our edition prints these passages unchanged and discusses them; see criticism of the essay.

What does our edition add?

Notes, the story of the Madrid lecture, twenty-four essays with sources, counterpoints and a worksheet. See our edition.

Is it available in Spanish?

Yes. The edition exists in English and Spanish.

Sources
  • Thinking School edition: We Are the Grandchildren, Julian Delphiki.
  • J. M. Keynes, Essays in Persuasion (London: Macmillan, 1931).