Study guide: An Apology for Idlers

A study guide for “An Apology for Idlers”, for a class, a seminar or a reading group. One session for the essay, one for the essays around it.

Before reading

  • When did you last spend an afternoon doing nothing useful? Did you feel guilty? Write down why.
  • Do you call your own free time leisure or idleness? Is there a difference?

The essay

  1. Stevenson writes an apology, a partisan plea, and says so. What does the essay gain by not being impartial, and what does it lose?
  2. What is lese-respectability? Who are the judges, and is the court still sitting?
  3. He says he regrets the dull hours in class, not the hours of truantry. Is that true of your own education?
  4. His truant learns “to play the fiddle, to know a good cigar, or to speak with ease and opportunity to all varieties of men.” Which of the three matters most now?
  5. Explain “Extreme busyness… is a symptom of deficient vitality.” Do you know anyone who proves it?
  6. “Thanks to hunger and the workhouse.” What does this half-sentence admit?
  7. Is being happy a duty, as he claims? To whom?

The essays around it

  1. “El Dorado” ends by saying the true success is to labour. Does it contradict the Apology?
  2. “Æs Triplex” argues for living fully rather than guarding against death. How does it change your reading of the Apology?
  3. Which of the seven essays in our appendix argues best against the Apology, and which defends it best?

Discussion

  • Stevenson’s truancy turned out well because he could afford for it to turn out badly. Does his defence of the school of the street still hold?
  • Is there a hobby in the group that could never become a business? Would you defend it if it could?
  • If idleness is a privilege, what follows: stop defending it, or share it out better? See idleness as privilege.
  • Compare Keynes’s fifteen-hour week (study guide) and Thoreau’s walks (study guide).

Exercise

Wait fifteen minutes somewhere public without a screen, a book or a task. Write half a page afterwards about what you noticed. Our edition’s essay on boredom explains why this is harder than it sounds.

Sources
  • R. L. Stevenson, “An Apology for Idlers”, Cornhill Magazine, July 1877; Virginibus Puerisque (1881).
  • Thinking School edition: An Apology for Idlers (Annotated), Julian Delphiki.