A study guide for “An Apology for Idlers”, for a class, a seminar or a reading group. One session for the essay, one for the essays around it.
Before reading
- When did you last spend an afternoon doing nothing useful? Did you feel guilty? Write down why.
- Do you call your own free time leisure or idleness? Is there a difference?
The essay
- Stevenson writes an apology, a partisan plea, and says so. What does the essay gain by not being impartial, and what does it lose?
- What is lese-respectability? Who are the judges, and is the court still sitting?
- He says he regrets the dull hours in class, not the hours of truantry. Is that true of your own education?
- His truant learns “to play the fiddle, to know a good cigar, or to speak with ease and opportunity to all varieties of men.” Which of the three matters most now?
- Explain “Extreme busyness… is a symptom of deficient vitality.” Do you know anyone who proves it?
- “Thanks to hunger and the workhouse.” What does this half-sentence admit?
- Is being happy a duty, as he claims? To whom?
The essays around it
- “El Dorado” ends by saying the true success is to labour. Does it contradict the Apology?
- “Æs Triplex” argues for living fully rather than guarding against death. How does it change your reading of the Apology?
- Which of the seven essays in our appendix argues best against the Apology, and which defends it best?
Discussion
- Stevenson’s truancy turned out well because he could afford for it to turn out badly. Does his defence of the school of the street still hold?
- Is there a hobby in the group that could never become a business? Would you defend it if it could?
- If idleness is a privilege, what follows: stop defending it, or share it out better? See idleness as privilege.
- Compare Keynes’s fifteen-hour week (study guide) and Thoreau’s walks (study guide).
Exercise
Wait fifteen minutes somewhere public without a screen, a book or a task. Write half a page afterwards about what you noticed. Our edition’s essay on boredom explains why this is harder than it sounds.
Sources
- R. L. Stevenson, “An Apology for Idlers”, Cornhill Magazine, July 1877; Virginibus Puerisque (1881).
- Thinking School edition: An Apology for Idlers (Annotated), Julian Delphiki.