A study guide for “Useful Work versus Useless Toil”, for a class, seminar or reading group. One session; the lecture takes about an hour to read aloud.
Before reading
- Name the most useful thing you made or did at work last week, and the most useless.
Questions
- Morris begins by questioning the idea that all work is good. Who held that idea in 1884? Who holds it now?
- List the three hopes. Rank them for your own work. Which is missing most often?
- “Mere toiling to live, that we may live to toil.” Is this a description of most jobs, or an exaggeration?
- Morris divides society into those who work and those who live on others’ work. Where would he put a software engineer, an advertiser, a care worker?
- What is the difference between wealth and waste? Name three things in your home that Morris would call waste.
- He imagines the factory among gardens. What would the office among gardens look like?
- How should machines be used, according to Morris? Apply his answer to artificial intelligence.
- The lecture ends expecting revolution. Does the argument depend on that expectation?
Discussion
- Who does the work nobody wants in a world of pleasant work? Morris never quite answers. Can you?
- Compare Stevenson’s idler (study guide) and Keynes’s fifteen-hour week (study guide).
Exercise: the scales
Our edition ends with questions for weighing your own work. Take one ordinary working day and score it from 0 to 3 on each hope: rest, product, pleasure. Add the scores. Then ask what one change would raise the lowest.
Sources
- William Morris, “Useful Work versus Useless Toil”, in Signs of Change (1888).
- Thinking School edition: Useful Work versus Useless Toil, Annotated, Julian Delphiki.