Study guide: Useful Work versus Useless Toil

A study guide for “Useful Work versus Useless Toil”, for a class, seminar or reading group. One session; the lecture takes about an hour to read aloud.

Before reading

  • Name the most useful thing you made or did at work last week, and the most useless.

Questions

  1. Morris begins by questioning the idea that all work is good. Who held that idea in 1884? Who holds it now?
  2. List the three hopes. Rank them for your own work. Which is missing most often?
  3. “Mere toiling to live, that we may live to toil.” Is this a description of most jobs, or an exaggeration?
  4. Morris divides society into those who work and those who live on others’ work. Where would he put a software engineer, an advertiser, a care worker?
  5. What is the difference between wealth and waste? Name three things in your home that Morris would call waste.
  6. He imagines the factory among gardens. What would the office among gardens look like?
  7. How should machines be used, according to Morris? Apply his answer to artificial intelligence.
  8. The lecture ends expecting revolution. Does the argument depend on that expectation?

Discussion

  • Who does the work nobody wants in a world of pleasant work? Morris never quite answers. Can you?
  • Compare Stevenson’s idler (study guide) and Keynes’s fifteen-hour week (study guide).

Exercise: the scales

Our edition ends with questions for weighing your own work. Take one ordinary working day and score it from 0 to 3 on each hope: rest, product, pleasure. Add the scores. Then ask what one change would raise the lowest.

Sources
  • William Morris, “Useful Work versus Useless Toil”, in Signs of Change (1888).
  • Thinking School edition: Useful Work versus Useless Toil, Annotated, Julian Delphiki.